How rebalancing really works — and why almost no one does it right

Keeping your portfolio in balance sounds simple, but most investors get it wrong—here’s how to rebalance the right way and protect your money.

Modified on:
September 27, 2025 5:00 am

Let me ask you something—have you ever looked at your investments and thought, “Wow, one part of my portfolio is growing faster than the rest”? Maybe your stocks have taken off while your bonds are sitting quietly in the background. That’s normal. But here’s the thing: if you don’t step in and adjust, your portfolio can slowly drift away from the balance you wanted. And that’s where rebalancing comes in.

What is rebalancing?

Rebalancing is simply adjusting your investments back to the mix you originally planned. Let’s say you decided to keep 80% in stocks and 20% in bonds. If stocks go up a lot, that 80/20 mix might quietly turn into 85/15. Suddenly, you’re taking on more risk than you agreed to.

Rebalancing fixes that. You either sell some of what has grown too much or add more money to the areas that fell behind. The idea isn’t to chase the hottest investment, but to keep your portfolio steady and in line with your goals.

Think of it like driving a car—you don’t just set the wheel once and hope to stay on the road. You make small corrections along the way.

Why most people skip it

Here’s the truth: very few people actually rebalance the right way. Why?

  • Some don’t even know they’re supposed to.
  • Others get nervous about selling something that’s doing really well.
  • And many people simply don’t have the time to track every little change.

The result? Their portfolios slowly tilt toward whatever asset is performing best. That sounds good in the short term, but over time it can expose them to risks they never signed up for.

How rebalancing really works

So, how do you actually do it? Let’s break it down step by step in plain English.

Step 1: Compare

Look at your current investments. Are you still close to your original plan? If you wanted 80% stocks and 20% bonds, but now it’s 85% and 15%, you’ve drifted.

Step 2: Decide

Ask yourself: Am I still okay with my original mix, or have my goals changed? Maybe you’re closer to retirement now and want to take less risk.

Step 3: Adjust

If you’re off balance, here are your options:

  • Sell some of what grew too much and put that money into the lagging asset.
  • Add new money into the weaker area instead of selling.
  • Use withdrawals smartly—if you need to take money out, take it from the side that’s overweight.

Step 4: Repeat

Do this once a year (that’s enough for most people). Some prefer twice a year or even quarterly. There’s no perfect rule, but the key is consistency.

Read later: 

Bad news due to historic COLA adjustment for Social Security benefits in 2026 – Increases of up to $672 will not be enough for…

Social Security ending paper checks at the end of the month: who still qualifies?

Good news about Social Security benefits – These are the millions of Americans who will receive checks of up to $5,108 this September 24

Major change at social security aims to help recipients

You Earn It, You Keep It’ Act would mean an end to tax on social security benefits

One thing you should never do to your Social Security card

Why it matters

Let’s be real: ignoring rebalancing can feel easier. After all, if stocks are on fire, why touch them? But here’s the catch—what goes up fast can also come down fast. Without rebalancing, you might be taking on way more risk than you realize.

By rebalancing, you’re doing two powerful things:

  1. Protecting yourself from big losses by trimming back the areas that got too heavy.
  2. Buying low and selling high without even thinking about it—because you’re automatically moving money from what’s up to what’s down.

That’s smart investing.

Can a robo-advisor help?

If all this sounds overwhelming, you’re not alone. That’s why robo-advisors exist. Services like Wealthfront or Schwab Intelligent Portfolios do the math and adjustments for you. You just answer some questions about your goals and risk level, and the system rebalances for you automatically.

It’s like having a personal financial assistant who never forgets to check your portfolio.

The pros and cons

Let’s be fair—rebalancing isn’t perfect.

Pros:

  • Keeps your risk in check.
  • Forces discipline (buy low, sell high).
  • Makes your portfolio steadier in the long run.

Cons:

  • You might reduce returns because you’re trimming winners.
  • It takes time and effort if you do it yourself.
  • It can create tax issues in taxable accounts.

But here’s the bottom line: the pros usually outweigh the cons, especially if you care about long-term stability.

Why almost no one does it right

Most people rebalance too little, too late, or not at all. Some rebalance way too often, which can actually hurt returns. The sweet spot is finding a rhythm that works for you—usually once a year—and sticking with it.

Remember, investing isn’t about making the most exciting moves. It’s about staying on track with your goals, even when the market gets noisy.

Lawrence Udia
Lawrence Udiahttps://polifinus.com/author/lawrence-u/
I am a journalist specializing in delivering the latest news on politics, IRS updates, retail trends, SNAP payments, and Social Security. My role involves monitoring developments in these areas, analyzing their impact on everyday Americans, and ensuring readers are informed about significant changes that could affect their lives.

Must read

Related News