If you run a small business, you probably already know how hard it can be to offer competitive benefits and still keep things simple. That is where Safe Harbor 401(k) plans come in. These plans make retirement savings easier for both you and your employees—without all the headaches that often come with traditional 401(k)s. Let us break down why this type of plan might be a smart move for your business.
What is a safe harbor 401(k) plan?
A Safe Harbor 401(k) is a special type of retirement plan that lets you skip the IRS’s annual nondiscrimination testing. For a lot of small business owners, that alone makes it worth considering.
To qualify, you need to make mandatory contributions to your employees’ accounts. But in exchange, you avoid the stress of having to prove that your plan is fair to both high earners and everyone else.
So in short:
- You put in a fixed amount for your employees
- They get full, immediate ownership of those contributions
- You skip the complicated testing every year
Why is nondiscrimination testing a problem for small businesses?
The IRS requires 401(k) plans to go through annual tests to make sure they are not favoring business owners or high-income earners. These tests include:
- Actual Deferral Percentage (ADP) test – Compares how much high earners contribute vs. everyone else
- Actual Contribution Percentage (ACP) test – Looks at the match amounts for different income levels
- Top-heavy test – Checks whether key employees hold too much of the plan’s total value
Here is the problem. If your business is small, you might not have enough employees at lower income levels to balance the numbers. And if you fail one of these tests:
- You might have to return contributions to high earners
- You could owe penalties or have to correct your filings
- Your team might lose trust in the plan
This is why Safe Harbor 401(k)s are such a relief for small business owners.
What are the employer contribution options?
With a Safe Harbor plan, you have to contribute to your employees’ accounts no matter what. But you get to choose how:
- Nonelective contributions – You give every eligible employee 3% of their salary, even if they do not contribute anything to the plan
- Basic matching – You match 100% of the first 3% an employee contributes, then 50% of the next 2%
- Enhanced matching – You offer a 100% match on up to 4% (or more) of an employee’s contributions
All of these options fully vest right away. So yes, even if someone leaves your business tomorrow, they keep the money.
How does a safe harbor 401(k) help small business owners?
For small businesses, this kind of plan can be a game changer. Here is why:
- No compliance stress – You avoid yearly IRS testing, which saves time and money
- Tax benefits – Employer contributions are tax-deductible
- Higher savings for owners – Business owners can save more for retirement without getting limited by failed tests
- Attract better talent – Many workers will not even consider jobs without a retirement plan
According to a Guideline study, 50% of employees said they would turn down a job offer if it did not include retirement benefit.
What are the downsides of a safe harbor 401(k)?
Of course, no plan is perfect. There are a few things to keep in mind:
- You must make the contributions every year—no skipping
- These contributions are immediately vested, so employees take them even if they leave quickly
- It may raise your overall payroll costs
Still, for many small businesses, the benefits outweigh the costs.
Can a safe harbor 401(k) be a roth plan?
Yes, you can absolutely offer a Roth option within your Safe Harbor 401(k). That means your employees can choose to contribute after-tax dollars, so their money grows tax-free and they do not pay taxes when they take it out in retirement.
What are the 2025 changes affecting 401(k) plans?
With the Secure 2.0 Act, there are new rules making it easier to save for retirement:
- Contribution limit is now $23,500
- Workers over 50 can make $7,500 in catch-up contributions
- Ages 60–63 can make up to $11,250 extra on top of that
- New plans must include auto-enrollment starting at 3%
- Part-time workers gain faster access to participate
These updates make Safe Harbor plans even more useful and appealing heading into 2025.
Related article:
What is frontloading a 401(k): does it make sense to contribute more to my 401(k) right now?
Homeowners can’t afford to ignore these tax breaks – How to use 401(k) or IRA Funds to buy a home
