In June 2025, a cautionary story in metro Detroit more clearly demonstrates just how advanced today’s scammers are. Carrie is a 56-year-old woman from Troy, Michigan, and she needed lower-cost car insurance and did what millions of Americans do every day – grabbed her phone and Googled an offer. This is a reminder of just how easily consumers can be duped by fake customer service scams.
After digging around, Carrie hit on what seemed like a legitimate Geico phone number. When she dialed it, someone answered gruffly saying “Geico,” and she saw no reason at that time to think anything was out of the ordinary. The voice was professional-sounding and informed, just the sort of thing she would expect to receive from the customer service representative of a big insurance company.
How the sophisticated scam went
The sophistication of the scam artists’ strategy was stunning. They didn’t even require payment in advance – instead, they established trust by asking her for details that were reasonable enough to request for the purpose of an insurance quote. They wanted Carrie’s driver’s license number, VIN number on her car, and even Social Security number. The imposter also directed her to dial an 877 number and sent her a text message from a 615 area code containing a link to what looked like a “Geico” form but was instead a Google Docs form intended to get her personal information.
The second most clever aspect of the scam involved the fraudulent partnership tale. The bogus agent reported Geico had partnered with Xfinity, her telephone company, on a deal whereby Xfinity would pay $28.23 of her first month’s auto insurance bill. The full price would be $428 to insure three vehicles, including two for her two young adult sons. In order to get this “offer,” she was to pay her first bill of $400 to Xfinity. She did.
Red flags that were ignored
There were a number of red flags that arose which, in hindsight, should have stood out from the very beginning. The imposter warned Carrie that her bank would inevitably bounce the payment for reasons that seemed reasonable at the time and advised Carrie to have her bank authenticate the transaction. This approach had a dual consequence: it kept her from questioning the reason why a credible insurance company would be required to have such unusual payment procedures, and it turned her into an active participant in the fraud.
The Xfinity offer was completely made up, but convincingly so, that it fooled Carrie. Large companies really do partner with each other, and the use of a specific dollar amount ($28.23) lent a sense of realism to the scenario that a rounded figure might lack.
How scammers get into search results
Success of such scams as Carrie’s relies heavily on scammers’ capability to control search engine listings. Scammers use sophisticated methods to place their fake customer service phone numbers in the top spots when customers search for legitimate companies. Cybersecurity professionals report that scammers use “search engine optimization (SEO) poisoning” – loading web pages with keywords and backlinks to trick Google’s algorithm to list their fake sites in front of actual sites.
The spammers may purchase their way onto top search pages by offering Google ads that display the fake numbers as sponsored listings, usually indistinguishable from genuine customer service information. They may also put up fake numbers on consumer websites such as Reddit or even build entirely fictional sites mimicking the real sites of big companies.
These tactics have proven surprisingly successful. Already, over 100,000 such scams in which the numbers for the bogus customer service lines were found using Google searches have been reported over the past year alone, with victims losing an average of $1,400 each. The problem is now so prevalent that it only took scientists 22 minutes to easily get Google to put a fraudulent business phone number in a prominent search results listing.
Protecting yourself from fake customer service scams
The most effective defense is verification through official channels. Rather than relying on search engine results for customer service numbers, consumers should visit companies’ official websites directly or use phone numbers from legitimate documents such as billing statements or insurance cards. When in doubt, hang up and call back using a verified number from the company’s official website.
Be immediately suspicious of any customer service representative who requests unusual payment methods. Legitimate companies will never ask for payments via gift cards, wire transfers, or cryptocurrency. They also won’t create artificial urgency by claiming your account will be suspended or compromised if you don’t take immediate action.
Watch for these additional red flags: representatives who pressure you for immediate action, requests for sensitive information the company should already have, or stories that seem too good to be true, such as exclusive partnerships or deals that require unconventional payment methods.
Read more: What are the highest paying summer jobs?
Read more: How much will you pay each month for a $1,200,000 mortgage?
