The projected 2.4% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for Social Security beneficiaries in 2026 has sparked widespread outrage among retirees, advocacy groups, and lawmakers.
At the center of the backlash is the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), the inflation gauge used to decide by how much benefits increase annually. Critics argue that the formula consistently underestimates seniors’ actual living expenses, fueling a growing gap between monthly checks and real-world costs.
The CPI-W Formula: A poor fit for retiree budgets
The CPI-W measures price changes based on the spending patterns of working urban households, giving greater weight to transportation (21.4%), food (14.3%), and apparel (2.5%), which are categories that do not align with senior spending. In contrast, Americans aged 62 and over typically spend:
- 41% of income on healthcare (compared to 8.6% in CPI-W)
- 33% on housing (compared to 32.5% in CPI-W, but with differing cost components)
- 12% on prescription medication (compared to 1.3% on CPI-W).
Over time, this mismatch has compounded. From 2000 to 2025, healthcare expenses rose 145% more than general inflation measured by the CPI-W. Housing costs for retirees also outpaced CPI-W inflation by 32%. According to the Senior Citizens League (TSCL), this divergence has caused Social Security benefits to lose 36% of their purchasing power since 2000.
2026 projection reignites long-standing complaints
The Congressional Budget Office 2.4% COLA projection for 2026—its lowest since 2021—has only intensified calls for reform. At that rate, the typical retiree’s monthly benefit would increase by only $48, to $1,968 from $1,920. But recent trends in inflation are already indicating even that small increase will fall short:
- Long-term care prices increased 5.3% in Q1 2025
- April 2025 medical device tariffs will contribute 0.7% to healthcare inflation through Q3.
“The CPI-W is akin to taking a thermometer specifically engineered for refrigerators and trying to take oven temperatures with it,” said Senior Citizens League’s Shannon Benton. “Seniors require a tool that accurately measures their economic reality.”
Legislative push for CPI-E builds momentum
Supporters increasingly support moving to the Experimental Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E), which reweighs categories to reflect retiree budgets. Analysis demonstrates:
| Metric | 1985–2024 Cumulative COLA | 2024 COLA Impact | Healthcare Weighting |
| CPI-W | +188% | 3.2% ($1,907→$1,922) | 8.6% |
| CPI-E | +211% | 4.0% ($1,907→$1,941) | 14.2% |
The Social Security Expansion Act of 2023 would require application of CPI-E to compute COLAs, increasing 2024 benefits by $15/month more than CPI-W provided. Although the CPI-E is not flawless—it lacks rural data, for example—supporters argue it is far more accurate for retirees than the current method.
2026 challenges could deepen the problem
Two coming factors have potential to make CPI-W deficit worse:
- Tariff-driven inflation: President Trump’s April 2025 tariffs—the biggest ever levied by the U.S.—are predicted to contribute 1.1 percentage points to CPI-W by December 2025. Seniors, however, can expect to be disproportionately affected by drug (9% more) and medical device (12% more) tariffs.
- Trust fund depletion risks: A higher-than-projected COLA would bring forward the depletion of the Social Security Trust Fund from 2034 to 2032, imposing 23% benefit reductions unless Congress responds.
A system on the edge
The CPI-W controversy highlights deep vulnerabilities in the social security system. While the average benefit will hit $2,000+/month for the first time in 2025, this milestone conceals a 25-year decline in real purchasing power. With 40% of retired employees having to depend on Social Security for 90% or more of their income, the stakes for COLA reform are higher than ever.
While lawmakers grapple with whether to switch to CPI-E or worry about trust fund adequacy, tens of millions of older beneficiaries face a dismal math: another year of benefits that cannot keep up with rising rents, physician copays, and grocery bills. So long as the COLA formula remains disconnected from retiree reality, the gap between Social Security’s promise and beneficiaries’ needs will continue to widen.
Read more: What is the special rule about earnings in the first year of Social Security retirement?
Read more: Social Security Calculator: How much Social Security payment will I get if I make $75,000 a year
