Bad news for retirees: despite COLAs buying power is falling

Why Social Security cost-of-living adjustments are not keeping pace with retirees’ real expenses

Modified on:
September 8, 2025 3:34 pm

Before retirement, most Americans probably imagine this: work for many years, pay into Social Security taxes, and later expect the benefits to help them live comfortably in the future. But nowadays, many Senior citizens have realized that with Social Security and the yearly COLAs, the buying power is diminishing. Prices of daily commodities are going up faster than these benefits can keep up, and this is quite such a concern for seniors.

What retirees are saying about their benefits

A recent study from Nationwide Financial shows just how tough things have become:

  • 52% of retirees say they had to cut back on discretionary spending because their benefits are not stretching far enough.
  • 31% are reducing spending on essentials such as groceries and medication.
  • 29% are dipping into savings or retirement accounts more often than expected.
  • 18% have downsized their homes to save money.
  • 15% are working part-time or finding other income sources.

Think about this for a second. Many retirees expect to relax in their later years, but instead, they are being forced to make sacrifices just to cover basic costs.

Recommended:

If you invested $1,000 in Intel 10 years ago, here’s how much you would have today

Why Social Security benefits are losing value

At first glance, it seems like the annual COLA should protect seniors. After all, it is designed to adjust benefits in line with inflation. But here is the issue: the formula used does not really reflect the spending habits of retirees.

The adjustment is based on the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W). This index measures the spending of workers, not older adults. Retirees, as you know, spend more on things like:

  • Health care
  • Prescription drugs
  • Housing and utilities

These categories have been experiencing higher inflation than the items covered in the CPI-W. That means the COLA, even when it seems like a decent increase, still falls short of the real inflation retirees are facing.

The Senior Citizens League, a well-known advocacy group, has warned that Social Security benefits have already lost around 20% of their buying power since 2020. That is a huge gap when you are living on a fixed income.

How this impacts everyday life for seniors

If you are retired, you may already be feeling this squeeze. Groceries cost more, rent and property taxes are up, and medical expenses seem to rise every year. Even if you get a COLA increase in January, it often does not feel like a raise. It feels like you are just running in place—or worse, falling behind.

This financial pressure is forcing many retirees to:

  • Delay bigger purchases like vacations or home repairs
  • Shop for cheaper alternatives at the grocery store
  • Skip social activities they used to enjoy
  • Lean more heavily on adult children for help

That is not the kind of retirement most people dreamed about.

Recommended:

How much is a home run ball really worth — and is it worth the fight?

What you can do if you are struggling

The reality is that Social Security alone cannot cover all your expenses. If you are finding it difficult to keep up, here are a few practical steps that may help:

  • Revisit your budget. Even small adjustments, like cutting unused subscriptions, can add up over time.
  • Avoid draining your retirement accounts too quickly. Once those funds are gone, it will be very hard to replace them.
  • Check for other benefits. Programs like SNAP, Medicaid, or energy assistance can provide real relief.
  • Consider part-time work. Even a small income stream can help cover rising costs without putting too much strain on your savings.

The bottom line is this: the system that is supposed to help you keep pace with inflation is not doing its job. And unless changes are made to how COLAs are calculated, retirees will keep facing the same financial pressure year after year.

Related article:

Good news for thousands of Americans – These are the Social Security retirees who will continue receiving physical checks after September 30

Not Miami or Chicago – The 25 U.S. cities where retirees can live well on Social Security for less than $2,000 a month

Bad news for millions of Americans – Social Security’s cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is shaping up to be a “total loss” for retirees

Enobong Demas
Enobong Demashttps://polifinus.com/author/e-demas/
I write on social welfare programs and initiatives for the United States, focusing on how these programs impact the lives of everyday Americans. My background in environmental sciences allows me to approach these topics with a unique analytical lens to provide my readers with a clear and well-rounded insight, eliminating the complexities often common with these topics.

Must read

Related News