When you file your taxes, especially as an immigrant, you probably expect that your personal information will stay private. But now, things are taking a different turn—and not in a good way. A new agreement between the U.S. Treasury Department and Homeland Security is shaking up the trust many immigrants have in the IRS.
Let us break it down simply, so you understand what is really going on and why many people, including those within the IRS, are raising the alarm.
Why is the IRS sharing tax data with ICE?
You are probably wondering—why would the IRS even think about handing over taxpayer information to immigration enforcement?
Here is what is happening:
- A new agreement was signed by the Treasury Secretary and Homeland Security that allows ICE to request certain private tax data from the IRS.
- This data is supposed to be used to help immigration officers find and possibly deport undocumented immigrants.
- According to the agreement, ICE must give a name, address, and explain how the info is related to a non-tax criminal investigation.
This is a big shift from how things used to be. In the past, the IRS had a strong reputation for keeping taxpayer info private, even from other government agencies.
Is this legal or breaking privacy laws?
This is where it gets messy. IRS lawyers have already warned that this move most likely breaks federal privacy laws.
- Tax information is protected under Section 6103 of the Internal Revenue Code.
- Even other federal agencies are not supposed to access your tax data unless very specific legal steps are taken.
So far, no one has said that these legal steps have been properly followed. In fact, this agreement was pushed through behind the backs of many top IRS officials.
Why did the acting IRS commissioner resign?
You may have never heard of Melanie Krause, but she was the acting head of the IRS. She has now decided to resign—and this new deal is a major reason why.
- Krause was not consulted when the agreement was made.
- She found out about it after the news broke on Fox News.
- IRS insiders say she felt powerless and believed the agency was being pushed in a direction it could not recover from.
One source said, “She no longer feels like she is in a position where she can impact the decision-making that is happening.”
How will this affect undocumented immigrants?
If you are undocumented but still pay your taxes (which many do), this could put you at serious risk.
- Wages earned by undocumented workers are still taxed like anyone else’s.
- Many file using an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) to stay compliant.
- Under this new agreement, that data could now be used to locate and deport you.
Basically, this deal breaks a long-standing trust. Immigrants used to believe they could pay taxes without fear of that info being used against them. That belief may now be gone.
What are the risks for the IRS and the public?
This move is not just bad news for immigrants—it also puts the IRS in a tough spot.
- It could destroy public trust in the tax system.
- It opens the IRS up to lawsuits, some of which have already been filed.
- If the IRS is seen as a tool of immigration enforcement, many people may stop filing taxes altogether.
John Koskinen, a former IRS commissioner, said it best: “It is unheard of that you would try to manage the agency from the Treasury Department.”
What happens next?
Here is what we know so far:
- Krause will stay in office until at least May 15.
- The White House is expected to make more cuts to IRS staff.
- Over 7,000 employees have already been laid off.
Meanwhile, immigration rights groups and legal advocates are working to block this new data-sharing plan in court. The outcome of that could affect millions of people across the country.
This is a fast-moving issue, and it is something you will want to keep your eye on—especially if you or someone you love could be impacted.
Continue reading:
Tax filing extension: iRS changes deadline in seven states
IRS Tax Relief Claim: How can you claim benefits if you were affected by a natural disaster?
