When tackling a home improvement project, it’s easy to rely on Home Depot’s vast inventory and one-stop convenience. However, a panel of experienced contractors and industry insiders warns that certain products sold at the big-box retailer often fall short in quality, fit or value. From preassembled cabinetry to ready-made doors, here’s what experts recommend sourcing elsewhere to avoid headaches, costly replacements and compromised results.
Custom vs. Store-bought cabinetry
While ready-to-install kitchen cabinets from Home Depot might seem like a budget-friendly shortcut, seasoned remodelers caution against sacrificing design flexibility and build quality. Thomas Borcherding, a residential remodeling contractor and owner of Homestar Design Remodel, notes that Home Depot’s cabinetry options—though plentiful in styles and finishes—often lack the precision and durability of custom solutions.
Local cabinetry dealers typically offer in-house design services and higher-grade materials, ensuring a tailored fit and finish that withstand daily wear and tear far better than mass-produced units.
Major appliances and limited returns
Home Depot’s extensive lineup of major and small appliances may tempt shoppers with bundle deals and seasonal discounts. Yet experts highlight the retailer’s tight 48-hour return window for appliances as a significant drawback. Borcherding emphasizes that most defects—ranging from faulty seals to malfunctioning components—only become apparent after a few days of use. Shoppers risk being stuck with a defective unit and incur additional costs for service calls or outright replacement if they discover issues beyond the two-day window.
Ready-made doors and windows
Perhaps the most critical caveat involves ready-made doors and windows. Wes True, general manager at Pella Windows & Doors of Omaha and Lincoln, explains that these stock units are manufactured to fit “most” openings, but older homes especially tend to have irregular framing and uneven walls. A seemingly great deal can quickly turn into an expensive retrofit when installers must shave, shim or reframe openings to accommodate ill-fitting products.
Beyond labor costs, improperly sealed doors and windows lead to drafts, moisture buildup, and higher energy bills—problems that custom-milled units from local suppliers can avoid.
Local-door flooring
Home Depot offers a plethora of flooring options from laminate planks to porcelain tiles. However, Borcherding points out that regional flooring dealers often provide premium materials sourced from specialty mills or manufacturers in tandem with installation crafted by expert professionals. Unlike national chains, these local showrooms are very often staffed by ex-installers who have switched to retail and can thus provide higher-caliber products with better craftsmanship.
Concerns about paint quality
Maybe the most broadly held opinion among contractors is to stay far away from Home Depot’s house-brand paints. An interior and exterior formulation suffers from low pigment concentration, uneven drying and low adhesion, states Dan Shirley of Chicago Handyman. Streaking, drips and a general subpar finish requiring multiple coats and time to fix are reported by users. Shirley suggests premium brands like Benjamin Moore or professionals-grade lines at paint counters, as they cover better, have good color accuracy and last longer.
Fixtures and specialty hardware
Ranging from plumbing fixtures to cabinet hardware items, Home Depot stocks a large selection of these accessories. Nevertheless, Gregg Cantor, president of Murray Lampert Design, Build, Remodel in San Diego, advised that only those things considered consumables—like caulking, tape, and dropcloths—be purchased there. Many of the fixtures sold at big-box retailers are constructed to lower price points, with thinner metals, plastics, and basic mechanisms that limit longevity and warranty coverage, he explains.
Such wholesale and specialty distributors are the fountain of seasoned tested issues of high performance and extended warranty for critical components considered in high traffic or moisture areas.
Read more: Good news for Target shoppers: expansion of next-day delivery across the US
Read more: Trump looks to end quarterly earnings reports: what does that mean for investors?
Read more: If you invested $1,000 in Walt Disney 10 years ago, here’s how much you would have today
