Fifteen years ago, a financial planner recommended an annuity, promising a 5% annual return on an $800,000 investment, with the principal returned upon death. The annuity provides just under $4,000 per month, but recent discoveries raise concerns. The fees amount to 3.5% of the principal, significantly higher than expected. Worse, the planner has been censured and successfully sued for inputting client information without permission. Now, the question arises: have you been taken advantage of, and is there any recourse?
First, you need a clear picture of your annuity. Request an up-to-date statement detailing its cash value and any surrender charges. Understanding the type of annuity you purchased is critical, as not all are created equal. Fixed annuities offer stable returns, while indexed or variable annuities often come with complex fee structures and hidden costs.
Hiring an independent financial expert, preferably a fiduciary Certified Financial Planner (CFP), can help you assess your options. Unlike commission-based advisers, fiduciary CFPs are legally bound to act in your best interest. A fee-only adviser, who charges by the hour or per project, can provide unbiased insights into whether keeping, modifying, or surrendering your annuity is financially beneficial.
Exploring legal and financial remedies
If you suspect unethical behavior, you may have grounds for legal action. However, because the annuity was purchased 15 years ago, the statute of limitations may limit your options. Before considering a lawsuit, take these steps:
- Gather documentation: Collect old statements, contracts, and any communication with your adviser. Look for discrepancies in fees or any misleading information presented at the time of purchase.
- File a complaint: If your adviser is still with a firm, submit a written complaint to their employer. Request a copy of the suitability assessment conducted when the annuity was sold.
- Escalate to regulators: If the firm does not resolve your concerns, report the case to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), your state’s securities regulator, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). FINRA, in particular, handles investor complaints related to misconduct in financial advisory services.
- Consult a lawyer: A legal expert specializing in financial fraud or insurance law can determine if pursuing a case is worthwhile. Keep in mind that legal fees could outweigh potential recoveries, making this an option only if substantial losses are evident.
Although some annuities provide steady income and tax benefits, others are notorious for excessive fees and misrepresentation. Given the time elapsed, recovering losses may be challenging, but taking action could prevent similar mistakes in the future.
Read this later: Bad news for Social Security retirees – Eight common mistakes that will lower your paychecks in 2025
Good news for COLA adjustment in 2026 – Social Security check increase up 0.6% but will take a major hit for millions of Americans
Good news about Social Security benefits – These are the millions of Americans who will receive checks of up to $5,108 this July 23
Bad news for women collecting Social Security checks – Here’s why they’re collecting $4,000 less per year on average than men in SSA payments
Goodbye to Medicaid in New York – More than 1.5 million people may lose their health coverage with these requirements in 2026
Do spouses get the 2026 Social Security COLA increase, and who qualifies?
Avoiding future financial pitfalls
To prevent another costly mistake, focus on buying financial advice, not financial products. Annuities, insurance policies, and high-fee investments often come with hidden incentives for advisers, leading them to push products that may not align with your best interests.
When selecting a new financial planner, ask direct questions:
- How are you compensated? Ensure there’s no incentive structure influencing their recommendations.
- Do you receive commissions for selling specific financial products? Ideally, choose a fee-only adviser who does not earn commissions.
- Can I document or record our conversations? Any hesitation may be a red flag.
The best financial strategies prioritize low-cost, passive investments, such as index funds or robo-advisers. Some fiduciaries, while ethically obligated to act in your best interest, may still choose investments that benefit their business more than you. Always cross-check their recommendations with independent research.
If you suspect wrongdoing in a financial relationship, act swiftly. While recovering past losses may be difficult, learning from the experience can help you make informed, confident decisions moving forward.
