Let’s be honest. Receiving an unexpected Zelle transfer can get your mind running-there is free money to be had or will be discarded. But the truth is quite different. Before you spend a single penny, it is essential to understand your legal obligations, possible risks of keeping those funds, and plans you should come up with to avoid forming part of a fraud or theft investigation. This article discusses the actions to take when one gets a Zelle transfer from an unknown sender and whether one can keep the money legally.
Understanding Zelle and its protocols
Zelle is an immediately available peer-to-peer payment service for many banks in the United States. Almost instantaneously, money is transferred between email addresses and mobile devices of the enrolled people making the system most convenient but also vulnerable to accidental or fraudulent applications. That is because funds arrive in your account in less than a minute, and under normal circumstances, there is little or no notice for many users against the mistaken or fraudulent deposit.
Banks do not automatically reverse Zelle transfers, even after the payment is balanced in your account; the normal procedure is for the sender to initiate the “request cancellation” action before the payment is claimed. After such a time, the sender cannot claim back what they have sent. The burden then shifts to you and your bank.
Whether under state or federal statutes, retaining money you know or should reasonably know does not belong to you opens you to the risk of criminal charge as a larceny or theft by deception. The doctrine of unjust enrichment forces a person who benefits from another’s impoverishment to restore at least the value of the benefit. In simple terms, if the money in your account is not your rightful income, you are required by law to return it.
Potential criminal liability
Spending or withdrawing the money could well be interpreted as a conversion of property. The state has prosecuted individuals for spending a portion of mistakenly deposited funds, even when those funds have resided in their accounts for days before they became aware of the error. Although prosecutorial discretion varies among jurisdictions, the consequences of indictment and restitution orders are very real.
For now, just treat that unexpected credit as being off-limits. Otherwise, any withdrawal or purchase made with these funds could easily be viewed as theft once the error is detected.
Verify with your bank or credit union
Immediately contact the customer service department of your bank. Ask them to check into the transaction, identification of the sender (if possible), and place a hold on funds pending resolution. Some banks block the money for a short time after the mistake has been detected concerning the deposit.
Suppose the sender’s name or contact happens to appear in your transaction history. In that case, you may be able to reach out and send them a very friendly note: “I received a Zelle transfer from you in error—please advise how to return it.” The sender should be guided by their own bank on how to proceed, not doing so based on a personal interpretation.
Document all communications
Record all the details about your phone calls, emails, or chats with your bank and the suspect sender. Make a note of dates, times, names, and reference numbers. This will save you from being accused in future if the sender claims you refused to return the money.
Usually, once the bank recognizes the error, it will even reverse the transaction at its end. Various banks refund the sender automatically after a few days in flagging the error. At times, they could ask you to fill out an affidavit or acknowledgment that the transfer was made in error.
Direct refund to sender
You could directly return the funds to the sender, either via Zelle or otherwise through an agreed-upon method like a check or ACH transfer. Be careful about giving back money: always use safe methods to prevent the possibility of the scam where the original “sender” turns out to be bogus.
In rare cases, the sender may demand you keep the money or claim ownership. If a legitimate sender insists you keep the transfer, request a written confirmation. Provide this to your bank; otherwise, the bank may still retrieve the funds to correct its ledger.
When you might be able to keep the money
There are almost no circumstances in which you would be legally able to keep an unexpected transfer:
- Sender’s explicit waiver: You clear and convincing evidence that the sender doesn’t want the money returned.
- Statute of limitations: If a sender fails to contest an erroneous payment within the period prescribed by state law (usually between one and three years), a court might declare the funds yours. However, this varies tremendously and is rarely advisable to rely upon proactively.
Risks of ignoring the transfer
Ignoring a non-compulsory Zelle deposit might lead to:
- Holds or freezes: Banks tend to lock your account while investigations continue on.
- Chargebacks or reversal: Banks can also debit accounts for recovering the amount within no time.
- Legal action: It is civil and criminal remedies available to the rightful owner or authorities over you.
Receiving an unexpected Zelle transfer from an unknown sender can tempt someone into such behavior, but spending the money is legally and ethically risky. Fewer damages will occur if immediate notification is done toward the bank contacting the sender, in case one can identify the sender, to return the money. Thus, you would act to prevent any future liability and maintain the integrity of the peer-to-peer payment system.
Read more: $1,702 stimulus check hits this week for Americans in one state; check if you’re on the list
