The Social Security Administration’s (SSA) 2026 cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is expected to be the lowest raise since 2021, ranging from 2.1% to 2.4% as of May 2025. This represents a sharp drop from the 8.7% jump in 2023 and represents a continuation of a pattern of small adjustments that fall short of keeping up with retirees’ costs. But the changing economic realities and policy imperatives may change this course, possibly easing the fiscal burden on more than 72 million recipients.
The 2026 COLA baseline: A byproduct of cooling inflation
The projected 2026 COLA is based on the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), which increased 1.79% from the third quarter of 2024 to April 2025. This modest inflation growth-fueled by moderating energy prices and subdued consumer demand-is indicative of a modest adjustment. The Senior Citizens League (TSCL) had preliminarily estimated a 2.1% COLA in 2026 in January of 2025, stating that substituting October–December 2024 data with July–September data would result in the figure slightly higher at 2.6%.
Historically, COLAs have averaged 2.6% over two decades, but recent volatility-from 0% during the 2010–2011 recession to 8.7% in 2023-highlights their sensitivity to macroeconomic shifts. While the 2026 projection aligns with pre-pandemic norms, critics argue the CPI-W fails to capture seniors’ unique spending patterns, particularly healthcare costs, which consume 15% of retirees’ budgets compared to 8% for younger households.
Inflation wildcards: Trade policies and economic uncertainty
President Trump’s threatened 25% tariffs on imports from Mexico and Canada are a wild card. Economists are concerned that tariffs will start a trade war, drive consumer good prices up as high as 4%, and turn disinflation around. Imported food and automobile parts, for example, would be more costly and would directly influence the CPI-W. The University of Calgary puts the cost of such a move at lowering U.S. household incomes by $800 per year while setting off retaliatory tariffs further tightening supply chains.
On the other hand, if the Federal Reserve continues to keep monetary policies tight and global supply chains return to normal, inflation may fall as low as 2% by 2025, according to George Washington University’s Peter Loge. This divergence shows the vulnerability of current COLA projections: unexpected energy market surges, geopolitical tensions, or unforeseen demand spikes can quickly rekindle inflationary forces.
Legislative reforms: The push for CPI-E implementation
Organizations like TSCL are putting pressure on to replace the CPI-W with the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E), which places greater emphasis on healthcare and housing-costs that represent over 50% of budgets of seniors. Social Security benefits have lost 36% of their purchasing power since 2000, and retirees would need an additional $516 in 2023 to be equivalent to 2000 buying power. The CPI-E, which measures spending by households with one or more 62+ members, increased 0.3% lower per year than the CPI-W from 1982 to 2021, and may therefore be a better basis for COLA calculation.
Legislative measures, like the Social Security Expansion Act, hope to require CPI-E application, but partisan gridlock has held up its passage. Switching to CPI-E in 2026 would increase the COLA with one stroke by 0.4–0.7%, sore relief for seniors already experiencing average 6% annual increases in the price of prescription medications.
Labor market dynamics and wage growth
Robust 2025 pay increases, fueled by a 3.8% unemployment rate and a tight labor market, would spur the COLA upward indirectly. Higher wages boost payroll tax revenues, temporarily supporting the Social Security Trust Fund. The projected insolvency of the fund in 2034, however, holds steady as increased revenue is offset by increased benefit payments to retired Baby Boomers.
Moreover, the SSA’s 2025 earnings limit to $23,400 for employees who are below full retirement age may inspire more to stay in the labor force longer, delay seeking benefits, and ease the system’s burden. The 8% increase in benefits for every year that claims are delayed after full retirement age is a tactic that only 10% of retirees now employ.
Read more: The Social Security email you may receive so you don’t miss your SSA paychecks: “There’s still time”
Read more: Farewell to Social Security payments on schedule in May – Here’s why checks will arrive later this month for millions of Americans
