Thousands of seniors this month have opened their mail to find Social Security checks slashed to as low as $750, as Democratic candidate Doug Huhn explains in this TikTok:
The reduction down to $750 is happening because of the resumption of student loan garnishment, which can potentially leave retirees with just $750 per month to live on. A Biden-era rule had protected a larger portion of Social Security benefits from seizure. The new Trump approach reverts to a decades-old garnishment policy that lowers the protected amount.
Furthermore, Democratic lawmakers are raising the alarm over what they call policies that “betray America’s seniors.” In addition to the student loan debt collections, Democrats are calling out clerical errors and administrative breakdowns, they say undermine the stability of the Social Security Administration (SSA) under Trump-appointed leadership.
How Student Loans and SSA failures cut benefits
As of May, the federal government resumed collecting on defaulted student loans by garnishing Social Security benefits, ending a five-year pause that began during the pandemic. The change also reinstated a decades-old policy that protects only $750 per month of a retiree’s Social Security income from seizure. That threshold hasn’t been adjusted since 1996.
This marks a reversal of Biden-era protections, which had shielded benefits up to 150% of the federal poverty line (about $1,883 per month) for low-income seniors. Under the current Trump administration policy, any Social Security income above $750 is subject to garnishment — meaning some older Americans could be left with just that minimum to live on.
According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, an estimated 452,000 retirees aged 62 and older are at risk of having their benefits reduced under this policy, putting many financially vulnerable seniors in serious hardship.
Meanwhile, an SSA computer failure in March 2025 mistakenly alerted Supplemental Security Income (SSI) recipients that they were “no longer receiving payments.” The bug, which deleted days’ worth of payment records, put families such as Chris Hubbard’s into a tailspin: “My son’s group home funding vanished overnight. We had no explanation, no recourse.”
Political backlash: “A coordinated assault on retirement security”
Democrats have criticized the president’s administration for undermining Social Security in the form of hiring reductions, efforts at privatization, and collaborations with business groups. During a May 2025 Capitol Hill demonstration, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) criticized nominee Frank Bisignano—a corporate-connected CEO backed by Elon Musk, as a “rubber stamp for benefit slashes”:
“Bisignano constructed his career by gutting workforces. Appointing him as Social Security commissioner is like installing a fox to guard the henhouse. Seniors deserve more than a commissioner who’ll first think about DOGE’s algorithms, not people’s lives.”
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) referenced operational deterioration: “Offices are closing, phones are not being answered, and now benefits are vanishing. It’s shameful of our dedication to our seniors.”
Systemic breakdowns: Agency in crisis
The SSA problems go beyond politics:
- Staffing shortages: 40% fewer field office personnel since 2020, 1-hour phone holds, and 6-month disabilities claim delays.
- Tech collapses: March 2025 website crashes kept 2.1 million retirees out of their accounts, while panicked “non-payment” notices created an uproar.
- Privatization fears: Bisignano’s advocacy of AI-based “fraud detection” and Musk’s request to label Social Security a “Ponzi scheme” suggest robo-denials of benefits.
Recent SSA mistakes (2025)
| Issue | Impact | Source |
| Student Loan Garnishments | 15% cuts for 450,000+ retirees | DOE Policy |
| SSI Payment Glitch | False “non-payment” alerts | CBS News |
| Website Crashes | 2.1M locked out of accounts | |
| Phone Service Reductions | 50% fewer agents since 2024 | Senate Probe |
The road forward: Safeguarding benefits under siege
Democrats have proposed emergency reforms, including:
- Ending garnishments: Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) has proposed legislation shielding Social Security from student loan collections.
- Blocking Bisignano’s nomination: 41 Senate Democrats have pledged to vote against him, citing conflicts-of-interest with Musk and DOGE-related platforms.
- Restoring SSA capacity: A proposed $1.2 billion funding boost would hire 8,000 workers and reopen 200 closed offices.
But broader threats loom. The Republican Study Committee’s 2025 budget, supported by 80% of House GOP members, proposes:
- Reducing lifetime Social Security benefits for average earners by $182,000
- Raising the retirement age to 69
- Privatizing Medicare
A defining battle for dignity in retirement
The reductions to a possible floor of $750 are part of a larger ideological battle. As Sen. Warren puts it, “This isn’t just about budgets—it’s about whether we value our elders enough to protect their lifelines”. With 52 million retirees on the line, the struggle over the future of Social Security is now a referendum on America’s values towards its elderly.
For the time being, beneficiaries are in suspense. In Hubbard’s words, “Every time I check my son’s account, I’m afraid it’ll read $0 again. We’re living through a nightmare no retiree should have to endure.”
Read more: This is the new $8700-a-year stimulus check being handed out in California – These Americans will collect tax relief starting in June
Read more: “It’s good for their self-worth”: the moral component of Trump’s big, beautiful bill and Medicaid requirements
