A huge shakeup may be brewing for the U.S. real estate market. President Donald Trump stated that he’s considering a plan to eliminate the capital gains tax on home sales—a move that might impact millions of homeowners and potential sellers across the country. This proposal arises when high property prices mean more sellers reach or exceed the federal exemption ceiling on gains on home sales, facing the possibility of huge tax bills. Were it to happen, the change would redefine home ownership incentives, home selling trends, and the nation’s overall economy.
Current law: The $250,000/$500,000 capital gains exclusion
Currently, U.S. tax law from 1997 provides homeowners with substantial relief from the capital gains tax when they sell their primary residence:
- Single filers get to exempt up to $250,000 in profit from tax.
- Married couples filing together get to exempt up to $500,000.
Eligibility:
- The home must be the primary residence of the seller.
- The seller must have lived in and owned the home for two out of five previous years.
- The exclusion can only be applied once every two years.
Profits beyond this exclusion—that is, any gain beyond $250,000 or $500,000, depending on filer status—are taxed as capital gains, with rates determined by a seller’s income and filing status.
Trump’s proposal: Eliminating capital gains on sale of homes
President Trump recently revealed that his administration is considering abolishing capital gains taxes imposed on the sale of homes. The idea is straightforward: Gains on the sale of a main home would no longer be subject to taxation, regardless of the gain. The action recalls the “No Tax on Home Sales Act,” a congressional bill introduced by GOP lawmakers, which seeks to abolish the federal capital gains tax on primary residence sales.
Trump has asserted that it would ease an ever-growing burden of taxes on millions of Americans, particularly those whose homes have increased significantly in value since they were purchased. The proposal is framed as a housing market stimulus and a way to bring fiscal help to long-time homeowners, including baby boomers who want to downsize.
Why the change matters now
Home prices have risen, especially in California, New York, and Massachusetts, pushing more homeowners over the $500,000 exemption threshold. In 2023, about 8% of homes sold for gains exceeding that amount, which means additional Americans are being caught off guard with big tax bills when they sell.
Immediate effects of the current law are:
- Coerces some long-time owners, particularly retirees, to stay in their properties (“lock-in effect”) rather than selling and bearing a heavy tax burden.
- Preventing turnover in the housing market, lowering inventory available for first-time buyers, like young families.
The exclusion threshold has not been updated since its establishment in 1997 to keep up with inflation, so existing homeowners are more likely to exceed the threshold.
Potential economic and market consequences
The proposed repeal of the capital gain tax on home sales would have wide-ranging effects:
- Stimulate home sales: Removing the tax would likely stimulate mobility as homeowners are more willing to sell, knowing their gains are fully protected.
- Housing supply increase: Additional listings could alleviate restricted housing markets, allowing buyers to more readily find houses.
- Wealth building: Retirees and long-term residents would be permitted to retain more equity, enhancing lifetime consumption and saving.
- Real estate cycles: The sellers in high-appreciation neighborhoods would be most immediately affected by the change.
Critics caution the federal government could forgo significant amounts of tax revenue and raise questions regarding long-term fiscal sustainability and fairness, especially with wealthier homeowners gaining the most advantages under a change.
Though President Trump’s endorsement has reopened the debate, the plan would require Congressional approval to be enacted into law. It also comes into a politically charged environment, with housing, taxation, and wealth inequality all being high-profile issues for campaigns.
Read more: What is the Volunteer Income Tax Assistance program and who is eligible?
